1958: “Body Beautiful” Musical Closes

In the world of theater, the closing of a show can be a bittersweet moment. It signifies the end of a production’s run, the culmination of months of hard work and dedication. On March 15, 1958, the musical “Body Beautiful” closed its curtains for the final time at the Broadway Theater in New York City. Despite the talent of its cast and the creativity of its team, the show struggled to find its audience, ultimately succumbing to the challenges and uncertainties of the Broadway scene.

“Body Beautiful” was a musical that aimed to captivate audiences with its blend of music, dance, and storytelling. Set in the vibrant world of bodybuilding, it followed the journey of a young man named Harry, who dreams of becoming a champion bodybuilder. With a score composed by Jerry Bock and lyrics by Sheldon Harnick, the musical had all the ingredients for success.

The production boasted a talented cast, with actors such as Steve Forrest, Jack Warden, and Barbara McNair taking the stage. The creative team, including director George Abbott and choreographer Bob Fosse, brought their expertise and vision to the show. However, despite their best efforts, “Body Beautiful” struggled to resonate with audiences.

The Broadway scene in the late 1950s was a competitive one, with numerous shows vying for attention and ticket sales. The success of a production often relied on factors such as word-of-mouth, critical reception, and effective marketing. Unfortunately, “Body Beautiful” fell short in these areas.

Reviews of the musical were mixed, with some critics praising the performances and music, while others found the story lacking. The New York Times, in its review, noted that the show had “moments of charm and humor,” but ultimately felt disjointed and struggled to engage the audience. This lukewarm critical reception may have contributed to the show’s struggle to find its audience.

Marketing and promotion also played a crucial role in the success or failure of a Broadway show. In the case of “Body Beautiful,” it seems that the marketing efforts may not have effectively conveyed the essence of the production. The show’s premise, centered around bodybuilding, may have been a tough sell to audiences who were expecting more traditional musical fare.

Furthermore, the timing of the show’s run may have also worked against it. In 1958, the Broadway scene was dominated by popular productions such as “West Side Story” and “The Music Man.” These shows attracted large audiences and garnered critical acclaim, leaving little room for other productions to shine.

Despite its struggles, “Body Beautiful” did leave a lasting impact on the Broadway scene. The musical featured the choreography of Bob Fosse, who would go on to become one of the most influential choreographers in theater history. Fosse’s unique style, characterized by precise movements and intricate staging, would be showcased in future productions such as “Chicago” and “Cabaret.”

The closing of “Body Beautiful” serves as a reminder of the ephemeral nature of Broadway productions. For every successful show that enjoys a long run and critical acclaim, there are countless others that struggle to find an audience and close prematurely. It is a testament to the challenges and uncertainties faced by those involved in the theater arts.

Today, the legacy of “Body Beautiful” lives on in the annals of Broadway history. While it may not have achieved the success it hoped for during its initial run, the show serves as a reminder of the resilience and determination of those who dare to bring their creative visions to the stage.


Excerpt: The musical “Body Beautiful” closed at the Broadway Theater in New York City on March 15, 1958, after 60 performances. Despite a talented cast and creative team, the show struggled to find its audience, highlighting the challenges and uncertainties of Broadway productions.

Leave a Reply